Understand keto vs carnivore diet basics
If you are comparing the keto vs carnivore diet to lose weight or improve your health, you are really looking at two different levels of low carb eating. Both focus on cutting carbohydrates and using fat for fuel, but they differ a lot in what you can eat and how sustainable they feel day to day.
At a glance:
- Keto is high fat, moderate protein, very low carb, and includes both animal and low carb plant foods.
- Carnivore is an animal products only diet, often called a zero carb approach, and eliminates all plant foods.
Both can help with short term weight loss and blood sugar control, but they come with different pros, cons, and long term risks. Below, you will see how they work so you can talk with your healthcare provider and decide what fits your body and lifestyle.
What the keto diet looks like
On a ketogenic diet, you aim to get most of your calories from fat, some from protein, and very little from carbohydrates.
Core keto principles
According to several overviews of the diet, the ketogenic diet is:
- High fat
- Moderate protein
- Very low carbohydrate, often about 20 to 50 grams of net carbs per day, which is far below standard dietary guidelines for carb intake (Groovy Keto, Health)
This carb restriction pushes your body into ketosis, a metabolic state where you burn fat for energy instead of glucose (Health).
Foods you eat on keto
You have a good amount of choice on keto as long as foods are low in carbs:
- Animal proteins: beef, poultry, pork, lamb, fish, eggs
- Fats: olive oil, butter, ghee, coconut oil
- Low carb dairy: cheese, heavy cream, some unsweetened yogurt
- Low carb vegetables: broccoli, spinach, zucchini, leafy greens (Groovy Keto)
- Some plant fats: avocados, nuts, seeds in moderate amounts (Health)
What you limit on keto
You generally avoid or sharply limit:
- Sugar in all forms
- Grains such as bread, pasta, rice, cereal
- Starchy vegetables like potatoes and corn
- Most fruits except small portions of berries
- Sweetened drinks and most ultra processed foods
What the carnivore diet looks like
The carnivore diet takes low carb to the extreme. It cuts all plant foods and focuses only on animal products.
Core carnivore principles
Research summaries describe carnivore as:
- A zero carb or near zero carb diet
- Exclusively animal products such as meat, fish, eggs, and some dairy
- Total elimination of fruits, vegetables, grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds (Archer Jerky, Groovy Keto)
Because there are essentially no carbohydrates, you typically enter ketosis quickly, often within a few days (Groovy Keto).
Foods you eat on carnivore
On a strict carnivore diet, your food list is short:
- Red meat: beef, lamb, venison
- Poultry: chicken, turkey, duck
- Seafood: fish, shellfish
- Eggs
- Some dairy: butter, some cheese, sometimes heavy cream
Some versions are more flexible and allow seasonings or coffee, but the core rule is that all your calories come from animal sources (People’s Choice Beef Jerky).
What you avoid on carnivore
You remove all of the following:
- Fruits and vegetables
- Grains and legumes
- Nuts and seeds
- Plant oils
- Sugary and starchy foods
- Most processed snack foods
Keto vs carnivore diet: key similarities
Even though keto and carnivore feel very different to live with, they do share some important features.
Both are very low carb
Both diets sharply reduce carbohydrates. Keto usually keeps carbs at about 5 to 10 percent of your daily calories, while carnivore aims for zero percent (People’s Choice Beef Jerky).
This low carb pattern:
- Reduces blood sugar spikes
- Cuts insulin needs
- Relies on fat, rather than carbs, for most energy
Both can trigger ketosis
Both the keto diet and the carnivore diet can put you into ketosis, where your body burns fat instead of glucose (Health).
- Keto uses a specific balance of high fat, moderate protein, and very low carbs to maintain ketosis (Archer Jerky).
- Carnivore usually leads to ketosis because carbs are essentially eliminated and fat becomes the main fuel source (Groovy Keto).
Both may support weight loss
When you compare keto vs carnivore diet for weight loss, both can be effective, especially in the short term.
Research summaries point out that:
- Keto supports fat loss by maintaining ketosis and often leads to steady weekly weight loss when calories are controlled (Groovy Keto).
- Carnivore can also reduce body fat because high protein and fat keep you full, which can reduce total calorie intake without tracking (Archer Jerky).
Both diets may also steady blood sugar and improve insulin sensitivity, which can make it easier to manage cravings and type 2 diabetes under medical supervision (Archer Jerky, Health).
Keto vs carnivore diet: key differences
The big differences show up in what you can eat, how flexible the diet feels, and what risks you might face over time.
Food variety and flexibility
This is usually the first thing you notice.
- Keto includes both animal and low carb plant foods. You can work in non starchy vegetables and some nuts, seeds, and low sugar fruits (Health, Groovy Keto).
- Carnivore excludes all plant foods and focuses strictly on meat, fish, eggs, and some dairy (People’s Choice Beef Jerky).
Because of this:
- Keto is generally easier to stick with socially. You can usually find something to eat at restaurants or family meals.
- Carnivore can feel limiting. Eating out or traveling becomes harder, and boredom can set in quickly for many people.
How structured each diet is
- Keto requires you to pay attention to macronutrient ratios. You track or estimate carbs, fat, and protein to stay in ketosis (People’s Choice Beef Jerky).
- Carnivore is very simple in concept. You eat animal products when you are hungry and you do not need to count macros or carbs because all your foods are low or zero carb (Bearded Butchers).
If you dislike tracking and enjoy meat heavy meals, carnivore may feel straightforward. If you want more menu options and feel comfortable tracking, keto may be a better fit.
Health benefits and evidence
Both approaches are popular, but not equally studied.
- Keto has a larger body of research. Studies support its use for weight loss, improved blood sugar control, and shifts in cholesterol profiles when done carefully (People’s Choice Beef Jerky).
- Carnivore relies more on anecdotal reports. Some people report weight loss and symptom relief, especially when they are sensitive to certain plant foods, but long term research is limited and raises concerns about nutrient balance and heart health (Health, University Hospitals).
Some individuals with gut issues or autoimmune symptoms say they feel better when they remove foods like gluten, some dairy, lectins, and oxalates. Carnivore removes many of these triggers, which may explain why some people notice short term symptom relief (University Hospitals).
Heart health considerations
When you compare keto vs carnivore diet for heart health, the details matter.
- Keto can improve HDL cholesterol and reduce LDL cholesterol in some people, especially when you focus on healthy fats and non processed foods (Archer Jerky).
- Carnivore is typically high in saturated fat, cholesterol, and often sodium. This raises concern that LDL cholesterol and heart disease risk may increase over time (Baylor Scott & White Health).
If you have a history of heart disease or high cholesterol, your care team may prefer a more balanced low carb plan that includes plant foods and limits processed meats.
Potential risks and side effects
Both diets come with trade offs. Understanding them helps you decide how cautious you need to be and when to involve a healthcare provider.
Digestive changes and fiber
- Keto can be low in fiber if you do not prioritize vegetables and other low carb plant foods. This can cause constipation or diarrhea, especially while your body is adjusting (Archer Jerky).
- Carnivore contains almost no fiber at all. Some people notice less gas or bloating at first, but long term fiber shortages can lead to constipation and may remove benefits like improved cholesterol, blood sugar stability, weight management support, and lower colon cancer risk (Baylor Scott & White Health).
If you value gut health and long term digestive comfort, this is a significant factor.
Nutrient gaps
Any diet that eliminates major food groups increases your risk of missing key nutrients.
On keto you may fall short on:
- Some vitamins and minerals found in high carb fruits, whole grains, and legumes
- Fiber if you skimp on vegetables (Archer Jerky)
On carnivore the gaps can be larger:
- Vitamins C and E and phytonutrients that usually come from fruits and vegetables
- Fiber
- Other micronutrients that are more abundant in plant foods (Archer Jerky, Baylor Scott & White Health)
High intakes of red and processed meat have also been linked with a higher risk of certain cancers, including colon and rectal cancer, which is a concern when you rely almost entirely on these foods long term (Baylor Scott & White Health).
Kidney and metabolic stress
Both keto and carnivore can stress your kidneys if you already have reduced kidney function, mainly because of higher protein and in some cases high fat intake (Bearded Butchers).
Experts also point out that very restrictive diets may not be sustainable and that you might regain weight once you return to previous eating habits (Health).
If you have kidney disease, diabetes, heart disease, are pregnant, breastfeeding, or have a compromised immune system, talk with your doctor before starting either diet, and be especially cautious with carnivore (University Hospitals).
Which diet is more sustainable for you
Your long term success has more to do with what you can live with than with which plan looks best on paper.
How long you can realistically follow each diet
A summary of current evidence suggests:
- Keto can be adapted into a long term lifestyle, because you can include a wide range of foods while staying low carb (People’s Choice Beef Jerky).
- Carnivore is often more suitable for short periods or as an elimination experiment, rather than as a permanent way of eating, because of its strict limits and nutritional concerns (People’s Choice Beef Jerky, University Hospitals).
If you are aiming for lasting weight loss and better health over years, not just weeks, a more flexible low carb pattern like keto usually fits better.
Social life and everyday practicality
Ask yourself:
- Can you join friends at restaurants without stress?
- Can you travel and still find foods that fit your plan?
- Will family meals feel normal and enjoyable?
With keto, you can typically make small swaps, such as choosing a bunless burger with a side salad instead of fries. With carnivore, you may need to skip many common dishes entirely or eat ahead of social events.
How to decide between keto and carnivore
You do not need to choose immediately. You can start by looking at your goals, health conditions, and your own preferences.
If your main goal is weight loss
Both diets can help you lose weight. You might:
- Choose keto if you want more variety and a better chance of maintaining your new weight over time.
- Consider a short, carefully monitored period of carnivore if you are curious, then transition to a more balanced low carb plan that includes vegetables and other nutrient rich foods.
If you have blood sugar or insulin issues
Both diets can improve blood sugar control by reducing carbohydrates and stabilizing insulin levels (Archer Jerky, Health).
Because of the lack of research and higher risk profile of carnivore, many clinicians lean toward keto or another balanced low carb diet for long term diabetes management. Always involve your healthcare provider when changing your carbohydrate intake, especially if you use medication or insulin.
If you have a history of digestive or autoimmune issues
If you suspect that certain plant foods trigger your symptoms, you might:
- Work with a professional to try a structured elimination diet, which might look similar to carnivore for a short time.
- Slowly reintroduce low carb vegetables and other foods that you tolerate so that you rebuild a nutrient rich, sustainable diet (University Hospitals).
Jumping straight into long term carnivore without guidance increases your risk of nutrient gaps and other complications.
Simple starting steps if you choose keto
If you decide that keto feels right for you right now, you can make gradual changes instead of flipping your diet in one day.
- Cut obvious sugars first
Remove sugary drinks, candy, desserts, and refined snacks. This immediately lowers your carb load and calorie intake. - Swap starches for vegetables
Trade rice, pasta, and bread for low carb vegetables like broccoli, cauliflower, zucchini, spinach, and salads. - Add healthy fats
Include sources like olive oil, butter in moderation, avocado, and fatty fish to help you stay full. - Prioritize quality protein
Build meals around meat, poultry, fish, eggs, and possibly some dairy, in portions that keep you satisfied. - Monitor how you feel
Expect a short adjustment period while your body adapts to using more fat for fuel. Stay hydrated and make changes with medical guidance if you have existing health issues.
Key takeaways
When you weigh the keto vs carnivore diet options for weight loss and better health, here are the main points to remember:
- Both are very low carb and can promote short term weight loss and better blood sugar control.
- Keto offers more variety by including low carb vegetables and other plant foods, and it has stronger research support.
- Carnivore is simpler in rules but far more restrictive and may raise more long term health concerns, especially for heart health, digestion, and nutrient status.
- Most experts consider keto or a similar balanced low carb diet more sustainable and safer over time than strict carnivore.
- Your best choice depends on your goals, health conditions, and how you feel after discussing options with your healthcare provider.
If your priority is long term, realistic change, starting with a flexible keto style approach and tailoring it to your needs is often the most practical way to use low carb eating to support your weight and overall health.
About the Author
